HomeOpinionDecolonize ourselves… is it difficult?

Decolonize ourselves… is it difficult?

Knowledge that questions you and problematizes what you know, what you are and even your way of feeling, knowing and perceiving is normal for generating anxiety, especially due to the way we are culturally constituted: there are attachments to forms. of thinking, by content and by the ways in which relationships are structured. Questioning what we have learned to take for granted or what constitutes us can make us feel uneasy, in a subtle or imperceptible way; and, later, we can come to feel that it overwhelms us, overwhelms us or annoys us, and can even cause irritability or mental rigidity.

The Venezuelan social psychologist Fernando Giuliani remembers that, in any process of (trans)formation, a deep psychological tension is produced, especially if what is challenging us disrupts our way of being-knowing-being: «It is not that you are going to discard the information that you had and you are going to incorporate the new, the other, like a banking education process. No! You may feel like you have a loss! Because there is an affective predisposition, which has a cognitive content: that information embraces a meaning. It is the attitude, the image, the figurative core (the symbolic universes), the roles, the expectations that people have of how to act in front of others that gives meaning to that information; Added to this is the need for certainties that we have learned with the modern method. To the extent that certainties are reiterated, contingently, with actions, they become part of the habitus (schemes that are formed into structures and installed in us, in ways of thinking, feeling and acting), and that also gives meaning to our lives. The construction of meaning is the oxygen of spiritual and psychological life, even when part of those meanings are habitualized, so that people (Giuliani points out) who have been trained in modernity/coloniality and, suddenly, begin to wonder in a workshop, in a class, in a community meeting about the knowledge we have, we require a transit. But it is not an automatic transition, in which one knowledge is exchanged for another, but rather the transformation itself of a mode of knowledge (which implies a way of life) where the historical experience of the subject is compressed. We may not even have the eyes to see the 'new' or the 'other'. Therefore, we must give space to problematization, not only to information spaces.

Understand what happens between us and the issue of the need for certainties is key to working on any meaningful pretension of decolonization. Modern rationality has installed in us the problem of conscience, the individual certainty of having a firm basis for knowledge, for our actions; that is, to not fall into the fear of a 'darkness' where nothing is stable. The question here would be: about what certainty? Be possessor of the truth, the true truth!

The will to dominate modern/colonial rationality, as Juan José Bautista explains, has generated the idea that what it produces is true. So, when a subject appropriates that knowledge and "empirically verifies that it has to do with reality," then he never questions it again or finds it difficult to doubt it. Five hundred years of modern history have confirmed that type of knowledge, which translates into a type of subjectivity. «Changing that is difficult. Modern knowledge has been naturalized in such a way, it has been subjectified in such a way, in Marx's language: it has been fetishized; That is to say: something of human production has become natural or divine,” says Juan José. And how one dialogues with the divine! Everything has already been said!

The Cartesian thought of modernity leads us to believe that there are or should be permanent, universal, "objective" limits and borders, to which we can appeal to understand ourselves. Thus emerges what Richard Bernstein calls cartesian anxiety. This postmodern philosopher explores this phenomenon, when he argues: «I do not see Cartesian anxiety only as an epistemological anxiety, but I see it as something that has a much more general meaning, something that has a political meaning, an ethical meaning, a religious meaning; So, in this general sense, it is very present in today's world. (…) There is anxiety, a product of uncertainty and fragmentation, and people desperately want something that they can take as a secure foundation. In the philosophical area, specifically, there are still people who think that, if you don't have indubitable foundations, then you can't escape a kind of bad relativism [in which every story is valid]."

The category cartesian anxiety It is ideal, due to its psychosocial reference and its pedagogical simplicity, also because it shows us the paradoxes of the processes of meaning construction. It is a category that challenges optimists who think that, with more information, consciousness multiplies; or those who, with a feeling of perplexity, ask themselves: "But... why don't people understand or why do they continue doing the same thing, if they have read enough decolonial literature?"; "Why does so-and-so see the colonial wound? Why don't others see it?" Narratives that, at their core, are deeply reductionist: they seek to understand the human from individual will and decisions, from pathology, from fear; without taking into account neither the dispositions nor the singular capacities that are configured in social relations, nor the power plots in the social fabric.

As far as this problem is concerned, we could go a long way with Richard Bernstein, but we could not follow him in his ontic or partial proposal to "exorcise Cartesian anxiety, get rid of it" and "free ourselves from its seductive power", beyond the objectivism and relativism; since it does not question the foundations of modern rationality and its ontologization policies. It is not only about recognizing that the anxiety is still very pervasive in us or that we are afraid to wake up from a dream about a world that does not exist; nor does it go exclusively through realize that, in no area, can we count on secure foundations, and that We must trust our good judgment, because there is no reason to think that we need certain and indubitable foundations to have good judgment.. Yes!, we can start from the recognition of Cartesian anxiety, but there are still some questions: what are the causes of this anxiety? How can we overcome it?

The "anxiety" of having ultimate truths is full of modern subjectivity. As we saw in our installment “Science Naked”, modern reason is built on a single truth: science. The subject - in the words of Juan José Bautista -, when he asks or investigates something, always puts himself in relationship with objects that he has in front of him; He always believes that the subject is something different from the object: not only is it outside the object, but it needs to distance itself from it and place itself above it. Juan José observes that, from modern rationality, when the subject thinks and reaches a conclusion, he believes that it is true, especially if it is logical. So, he produces a type of subjectivity: the subjectivity of the individual's certainty (I am enough to know or know myself). What does this mean? That the problem of modern knowledge is the subject-object relationship: what is problematic is the object, not the subject. That is, the subject, in principle, is fine, although reality questions it. On the other hand, the trap of consciousness means that ideas are mere ideas: I can take them out, accumulate them or change them, and they do not affect me in my corporeality, in my subjectivity. They forget that ideas constitute, materially, the way the brain operates: «Every time one says: “Ahh!, I understand”; He is making synapses—and not between one neuron and another—between neuronal groups. When a type of knowledge is repeated several times, that type of connection solidifies it, so much so that... forms of thought, in the end, become a way of being and existing. The process that this decolonial teacher describes has a criterion that allows a deeper understanding: for something to prevail, it not only exists as a “true” idea, but as an idea that is practiced, applied and circulates, in various contexts. Thinking and doing determine being. In that living, one weaves one's body and its materiality.

In this way of knowing, not even the left of the global South is saved. Critical leftist thoughts are also fetishized, a product of the modern way of knowing. Power-knowledge produces subjects and produces practices. There are groups that gather around notions that acquire a “sacred” dimension. How does this problem present itself to us? Hegel's words explain it perfectly: "The individual appropriates the object in such a way that he strips it of everything that constitutes its particularity, converts it into an instrument and gives it its own subjectivity as its substance." It is a constitutively perverse worldview, ethically speaking. In her essay “The Path of Every Ideology,” ecofeminist Susan Griffin describes how theories and ideas that arise in opposition to the system end up being subsumed by this subjectivity and become exactly what they claim to question: “… when a theory becomes ideology, begins to destroy self-awareness. Born, at first, from feelings, it seeks to place itself above feelings, sensations. It organizes the experience according to itself, without reaching it. By the mere fact of being what it is, it pretends to be right. To invoke the name of that ideology is to summon the truth. Nobody can say anything new. The experience stops surprising her, traversing her, transforming her. He gets upset by any detail that doesn't fit into his worldview. It began as a cry against the denial of truth, and now it denies any truth that does not fit into its scheme. It began as a way to restore a sense of reality, and now it is about disciplining real people, remaking them in its image. Everything that he cannot explain becomes his enemy. It began as a liberation theory and is now 'threatened' [the quotes are mine] by new liberation theories; build a prison for the mind. Critical left-wing sociological or philosophical thoughts also reproduce or can reproduce abstract and homogenizing categorical systems; That is, they also reproduce or can reproduce political ontologies of domination.

That is the colonial wound and the geopolitics of knowledge. But it is not only a cognitive problem, it is an existential issue, in JJ Bautista's approach: in the sense of a form of existence, a way of life, whose specificity allows us to think about this type of problem in different ways. Where do I want to go? To this idea that the author of the book exposes What it means to think 'from' Latin America: the subjectivity of the modern subject always becomes existential loneliness, because, at its foundation, there is neither the human community nor non-human nature. Therefore, no problem is made when it attacks mother earth; Well, deep down, he believes that he is beyond non-human nature: that he can create another non-human nature. He is the guy who becomes god! In other words: he also believes that, for this, science, technology and capital are enough, which is what his egoity has created.

The trap of conscience and its anxiety for certainties, more than a struggle of reason, is a struggle for power: the fear of not losing authority. However, it must be noted that it is not just a matter of individual will or decision, as some say: "As their power is based on that knowledge, since they are authoritarian, they do not want to loosen it. If they were real researchers, they would be happy when they find a new possibility to investigate what is different. That would be a reductionist discourse, based on the myth of will. To repeat it would be to ignore that what is real is what is relational and that what we know or know also becomes spirituality in us and is part of our identity: it becomes a way of being-doing and being in the world. The way we have learned and the type of knowledge we have learned becomes spirituality and, in Bourdieu's category, dispositions that operate as generating and organizing principles of practices and representations, that is, story made body. The feeling of uncertainty is very difficult to sustain, psycho-communally speaking: it puts you on alert. If a part of your identity is fractured, your entire floor moves.

But I will be told: what should we do and what can we do in the face of that situation on which you invite us to meditate? The first thing is that the answer is not simple: there are no recipes, nor guarantees. What is fundamental is reject amnesia and the concealment of contradictions, as a method. The ontological turn (that is, of principles or foundation) is necessary: ​​we should not continue doing research or generating critical thinking with the modern mentality; that is to say: with the same criteria of domination of the modern-Western worldview and its Eurocentric prejudices. It is up to us to go beyond that it and move, in the words of Juan José Bautista, to the level of reflection or self-awareness. What is this plan? The place where the subject no longer faces reality as if everything that exists outside of it were objects, but discovers that, behind every object, there are always presupposed subjects, who through subjective action establish objectivities.

Humanity must transform the entire horizon of beliefs that modernity has imprinted on our subjectivity. We can only arrive at decolonial critical thinking when we discover that everything is a subject (that there is no separation between what is human and what is natural), that is, that everything has dignity. In this subject-subject relationship, the research subject learns to recognize himself as part of the problem he wants to reflect on. What is characteristic of thinking is "when consciousness," emphasizes the teacher Juan José Bautista, discovers not only that behind everything that appears before the eyes there are always the subjects, but that behind the appearance of every human being there is always, as a presupposition, a whole horizon of beliefs, ideologies, myths, worldviews, utopias, etc.; that give meaning to their actions and their entire life, and that in turn serve as a horizon of knowability and meaning of reality, which shows or teaches that, ultimately, the subject is in relation to the whole of reality. , although at first glance it may not seem like it, that is, in every act or action of any human being, what is always presupposed is a cultural or civilizational horizon.

What is it that allows us to surpass the margins of the subject-object relationship? Commit ourselves to the practical use of reason, from an ethics of life, as the philosopher Enrique Dussel has inspired us. Being willing, seriously and honestly, to listen to and understand what the other tells me and reflect on it, without ontologizing it or romanticizing it, but understanding it from their position in the social space and from the implications of the cartographies of power. It will be necessary to use "reason" to interpret a "meaning": "The description of the cause (the why) of suffering requires going from personal, private structures (ontogenetic or biographical), to social and historical, public ones (phylogenetic). or economic-political)».

Another proposal that offers us a way—thought by the Mexican sociologist Karina Ochoa—is to propose the decolonial critical debate not as a univocal reference, but as coordinates that allow us to understand the structures and networks of power interwoven in our daily dynamics, to make relevant displacements and illuminate, with understanding, what happens in our reality, in terms of relationality, culturality and complexity (not to theoretically fight with the fashionable intellectual!). To assume this position is to recognize that discourses serve to trap, capture and produce, at the same time as they silence and promote.

Likewise, we must do an exercise to make this type of decolonial critical thinking content embraceable by all people, even for those who are not in the field of philosophy or social sciences. This implies understanding that the contexts of discussion are heterogeneous and that, in each historical, economic and social space, speech has its particularities. Furthermore, assuming that, as a result of the encounter with the same or the different - and our understanding of the meaning of their objections, their thoughts, their procedures - our way of thinking and exposing arguments can be transformed; Some concepts and some central categories of our approach can even be transformed.

To the extent that we can vibrate with reality and its contradictions (and see how different realities occur), patient reading, movement to worldviews that have solidarity as a principle, as action, as praxis, as politics and as reason, and the recognition of otherness, we will be able to identify the colonial wound and change our ways of doing, of relating, of knowing(us), of thinking(us).

Loading…

1 COMMENT

  1. Very lucid and enlightening!!!! And the books mentioned allowed me to navigate other horizons. Thank you so much.

Leave a response

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here